Apply For a Job

Clay Tile vs. Asphalt Shingles: Best Roofing Materials for Fountain Hills Homes, Arizona

June 06, 2025
5 min

In Fountain Hills, Arizona, choosing the right roofing material isn’t just about curb appeal, it’s about protection. With relentless sun, scorching heat, sudden monsoons, and strong winds, your roof must withstand extreme conditions year-round. Many homeowners ask us whether asphalt shingles vs clay tile offer better value and durability in this harsh environment.

At Real Roofing, we have installed thousands of roofs across Arizona and know that the “best” roofing material depends on your needs and budget. This guide breaks down the pros and cons of clay tiles and asphalt shingles, the most popular choices in Arizona and help you make an informed choice that fits Fountain Hills’ unique climate.

June 06, 2025
5 min

Table of Contents

⛔ What Arizona Climate Demands From Your Roof

Arizona’s intense sun and heat don’t just warm your roof, they degrade it. UV rays wear down coatings, cause cracks in adhesives, and dry out underlayments over time. Then come the monsoon storms, bringing heavy, wind-driven rain that can exploit even the smallest weakness in your roofing system. What looks like minor damage can quickly lead to costly leaks and repairs if left unaddressed.

At Real Roofing, we specialize in roofing solutions designed to endure these conditions, helping homeowners protect their homes with confidence.

⛔ Clay Tile Roofing: High-End Longevity

Let's first talk about clay tiles. They work with Arizona’s heat, not against it. It reflects the sunlight, allows airflow beneath the surface, and complements the architecture of many Fountain Hills homes.

If installed properly, a clay tile roof can last for 50 years or more. These roofs can resist fire, pest infestations, and heat, do not need major maintenance, and add long-term value to a home.

But they come with some challenges, like they are heavy and can require structural reinforcement, and also crack if stepped on carelessly. Now, the tiles look solid, but it’s the underlayment beneath them that provides waterproofing, and this layer has to be checked quarterly.

We inspect tile roofing systems thoroughly, looking beyond surface damage to catch issues with the underlayment before they escalate.

Asphalt Shingles: Flexible, Budget-Friendly Protection

⛔ Asphalt Shingles: Flexible, Budget-Friendly Protection

Coming to Asphalt shingles, they are more common and affordable. In Fountain Hills, they are a practical option for people looking for protection without the high cost.

Modern shingles are much stronger than they used to be. The Architectural varieties offer thicker coverage and resistance to extreme heat and wind. When installed professionally and maintained, they can last up to 30 years.

The intense Arizona heat can cause shingles to deteriorate, leading to peeling, granule loss, and curling at the corners. Also, the storm winds can lift sections that once sat flush.

That is why we recommend upgraded shingles for homes that require a durable and reliable roofing solution. They’re not only easier to install, but they can be easily repaired when storms hit one section of the roof, leaving the rest intact.

⛔ The Basic Difference Between Shingles and Tiles

The Basic Difference Between Shingles and Tiles

✓ Where Shingles Win and Where They Don’t

Shingles are a good choice for homes with tight deadlines or budget issues. They can be quickly installed, and the ease of matching and patching makes them a convenient option.

However, shingles require frequent inspection and are prone to wind and water damage. So, to keep everything in check, we offer seasonal inspections. A five-minute quick inspection around the roof can help identify the minor issues before they escalate into an expensive repair.

✓ Where Tile Shines and What It Needs

Clay Tiles, on the other hand, are known for their durability, and they do not fade much under the sunlight or absorb too much heat. It offers a perfect blend of durability and design.

But, just like any other material, they have to be checked. Many Arizona homeowners believe that a good-looking tile roof is a healthy one, but in reality, water damage usually starts underneath the surface. If somehow the underlayment breaks down or flashing is incorrectly installed, you are prone to leaks and damage, which further leads to potential water damage and structural issues.

During our inspection, we carefully check for hidden weak spots at transitions, seams, valleys, and everything storms target first.

✓ The Hybrid Approach

Some homes in the locality use both tiles and shingles, with tiles in the front for style and shingles or foam in the back for cost efficiency. This combination works well.

However, the transition lines between the materials need attention, as these are some of the most common leak points. Our experts carefully inspect hybrid roofing systems to reinforce vulnerable transition points before the storm season arrives.

⛔The Real Roofing Approach

When comparing a clay tile roof vs asphalt shingles, it's crucial to consider long-term maintenance and climate fit. Choosing between a clay tile roof and asphalt shingles isn't just a style difference, it affects how your home handles heat, wind, and water.

We simply don’t push one material over another. We carefully examine the roof, check the structure, and ask the right questions. For example, how long do you plan to stay? What matters more to you, initial savings or long-term value? What does the framing allow for? What kind of maintenance schedule fits your lifestyle?

Once we assess these answers, we recommend what fits your home best.

⛔ Before You Decide

Ask yourself the right questions.

Are you staying long-term or selling in a few years?

Can your current structure handle the weight of tile?

Do you want something that looks sharp now or lasts longer down the line?

Are you willing to budget for small, regular checkups to avoid large, sudden repairs?

We’re here to help you weigh the pros and cons, so you can make an informed decision tailored to your home and lifestyle

⛔ After Installation: Staying Ready

Choosing the correct material is just the beginning. Your roof isn't a one-time investment, it needs frequent check-ins. Small inspections before and after the season can save thousands of dollars in surprise damage.

At Real Roofing, we provide storm-prep inspections and ongoing maintenance to keep your roof ready for anything. Our experts also look at things that most homeowners forget, like satellite brackets, solar mounts, gutter joints, and tree overhangs.

⛔ Real Roofing’s Takeaway

The right material matters, but the right maintenance plan matters more. Whether you choose shingles, tile, or a mix of both, the loop you installed today will perform as well as the care it receives tomorrow.

If you’re unsure which roofing option suits your Fountain Hills home best, our technicians are ready to provide a thorough assessment and honest advice. Schedule a consultation with us at Real Roofing to secure the perfect roofing solution for your home before the next monsoon season.

Need help with Your Roofing?

Partner with Real Roofing to boost property value, ensure client satisfaction, and gain a market advantage.
Contact Us Today