How to Choose the Right Roofing Material

⛔ Before You Pick a Material, Get These Factors Straight

Roofing isn’t just about picking what looks good. It’s about finding what actually works—for your home, your climate, and your plans.

Here’s what should shape your decision before you even start comparing materials:

1. Climate and weather exposure

Roofs that handle Arizona heat might not last in Utah snow. Live near the coast? Salt and moisture can eat away at some materials faster than others.

2. Your budget today vs your costs over time

Some materials are affordable up front but need more upkeep. Others last 40+ years with minimal maintenance but come with a higher price tag. Decide whether you’re spending more now—or more later.

3. What kind of roof you actually have

Flat, steep, gabled, low-slope—it all matters. Some materials aren’t meant for steep pitches. Others don’t drain well on flats. The shape of your roof limits (and guides) your options.

4. Any HOA or local restrictions

Some areas don’t allow wood shake. Others require certain fire ratings or color ranges. Check before you fall in love with a material that gets rejected.

5. How long you’re staying

If this is a forever home, invest for the long haul. If it’s a flip or short-term rental, you may have different priorities. And that’s fine—as long as your roof choice reflects it.

⛔ Your Real-World Roofing Options—And Where They Shine

Before you choose, you need to know what’s real. These are the materials that actually hold up out here—where heat, hail, and wild weather push roofs harder than most people realize. Some are built for the long haul. Some are great short-term. We’ll show you what fits where—and why.

1. Asphalt Shingles

You’ve seen them everywhere—and for good reason. They’re affordable, quick to install, and do their job well enough for most homes, especially short-term ones.

Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners, fast installs

Watch for: Shorter lifespan in extreme heat without proper ventilation

Good to know: Great if you’re selling soon or want curb appeal without overspending

2. Tile Roofing (Clay or Concrete)

Hot climate? Tile’s built for it. Heavy, durable, and made to last—this is what you want if you’re staying put and don’t want to think about your roof again for decades.

Best for: Long-term homeowners, premium curb appeal

Watch for: Your structure needs to support the weight

Good to know: Low maintenance, but cracked tiles can be a pain to replace

3. Metal Roofing (Steel or Aluminum)

Modern, tough, and cooler than you’d expect—literally. Metal reflects heat, lasts forever, and shrugs off most weather. Not cheap, but worth it if you’re in it for the long haul.

Best for: Energy efficiency, wildfire zones, homes built to last

Watch for: Higher upfront cost, not everyone loves the look

Good to know: Noise? Not an issue with the right install

4. Foam Roofing (Spray Polyurethane Foam)

Flat roof? Foam’s your friend. It insulates, seals, and keeps water out in one shot. Great for desert climates and energy bills, if you’re okay with periodic recoats.

Best for: Flat roofs on homes or commercial buildings

Watch for: Needs re-coating every 5–10 years

Good to know: Seamless waterproof layer = fewer leak risks

5. TPO Roofing (Thermoplastic Membrane)

More common in commercial spaces, but showing up on flat-roof homes too. It’s clean, reflects heat, and keeps the budget tight.

Best for: Flat roofs, garages, or budget-friendly rentals

Watch for: Not designed for visible or steep-pitched roofs

Good to know: UV-resistant, fast to install

6. Wood Shake

Rustic and eye-catching—but higher maintenance. Shake gives your home serious character, if you’re up for the upkeep and local codes allow it.

Best for: Older homes with character, mountain or cabin-style builds

Watch for: Fire risk, high maintenance, and local restrictions

Good to know: Some fire-prone areas (like parts of CA) won’t allow it at all

⛔ What Actually Works—Based on How You Live

No one shops for roofing materials just for fun. You’re here because you have a real decision to make—and it should fit your house, your plans, and your lifestyle. Let’s break it down in plain terms.

✓ If you’re selling soon: 

Asphalt shingles make the most sense. They’re affordable, fast to install, and give the house a clean finish buyers expect. No need to overbuild if you’re walking away in a few years.

✓ If this is your forever home: 

Go for tile or metal. You’ll pay more upfront, but they last decades with barely any upkeep. When you don’t want to deal with roofing again for a long time, this is the move.

✓ If you live in triple-digit heat most of the year: 

Tile handles it like a champ. Metal reflects sunlight and drops indoor temps. Foam, if your roof’s flat, adds insulation and energy savings. Any of those will outperform shingles in high heat zones.

✓ If you want as little maintenance as possible: 

Metal or tile. They don’t peel, rot, or need frequent fixes. Foam’s solid too—just remember the recoat schedule. Wood shake? Not for you.

✓ If you’ve got a flat roof: 

It’s either foam or TPO. Shingles and tile aren’t made for flat surfaces. Foam gives you insulation. TPO is cost-effective and gets the job done.

✓ If you care about curb appeal: 

Wood shake stands out. So does tile, especially Spanish or Mediterranean styles. Metal works great if the house has a modern look. Asphalt? Still looks good—just more common.

This isn’t about picking the “best” material. It’s about picking what fits your setup.

⛔ Mistakes That Lead to Regret 

Some roofing mistakes are small. Others show up five years later as leaks, sky-high utility bills, or a roof you now have to rip off and redo.

Here are the most common missteps—and how to avoid them.

✓ Picking the cheapest bid without asking why it’s cheap

There’s always someone who can undercut. But they usually do it by skimping on ventilation, flashing, or underlayment. That savings disappears the moment something fails.

✓ Choosing a material your structure can’t support 

Tile’s great—until your framing says no. We’ve seen homes crack under the weight of roofing they weren’t built for. Always match the material to your load-bearing setup.

✓ Ignoring how hot your roof gets  

Not all materials deal with heat the same way. In places like Phoenix or Palm Springs, choosing a roof that holds heat instead of reflecting it will turn your AC into a full-time job.

✓ Overlooking fire restrictions or HOA rules 

Wood shake might look great in your mind—but if your area bans it for fire risk, that dream’s dead. HOAs can also be strict about colors, styles, and materials.

✓ Assuming all roofs are “set and forget” 

Every roof needs something—cleaning, inspections, occasional sealant or recoat. But if you pick a high-maintenance material thinking it’s hands-off, you’ll feel it later.

Most regrets come from rushing. Roofing’s one of those choices where slower is smarter.

⛔ Still Unsure? Here’s the Move That Pays Off Every Time

You don’t need to become a roofing expert. You just need someone who knows what works in your area, for your kind of home, and your kind of budget.

That’s where we come in.

At Real Roofing, we don’t just show up with one solution and push it hard. We ask the right questions:

What matters more to you—longevity or price?

Is this your forever home or a quick flip?

What’s the roof actually dealing with—sun, storms, snow?

And how much maintenance do you realistically want to deal with?

Once we know those answers, we’ll lay out a few smart options—no pressure, no sales script.

Sometimes that means asphalt. Sometimes tile. Sometimes we’ll tell you not to reroof yet at all.

If you’re even thinking about a roof, let’s talk before decisions get expensive.

⛔ The Roof You Choose Will Do One of Two Things

It’ll either hold up without hassle—or it’ll become one more thing you’re constantly fixing, worrying about, or paying for.

This isn’t about picking the fanciest material. It’s about picking what fits your home, your weather, your budget, and your timeline.

If you want help figuring that out, Real Roofing is here when you’re ready. We’ll give you straight answers, show you what makes sense, and never push you toward something you don’t need.

Let’s get your roof done right the first time.
Reach out, ask the questions, and we’ll walk you through the rest.

‍